Deciphering Yehuda

Method Missing

Deciphering Yehuda

Gregg Pollack

Deciphering Yehuda

by Gregg Pollack

The talk titled Deciphering Yehuda by Gregg Pollack at the LoneStarRuby Conf 2010 centers around the advanced Ruby design patterns and techniques developed by Yehuda Katz in the context of Rails 3. Pollack aims to demystify Yehuda's refactoring work, making it accessible to both beginner and expert Ruby developers.

Key points covered in the talk include:

Introduction to Yehuda Katz's Contributions: Pollack highlights the significant role of Yehuda Katz in the refactoring of Rails 3 and mentions collaborators like Carl Lurch and Josh Peek.
Important Techniques Explored: Several advanced programming techniques are discussed:
- Method Compilation vs. Method Missing: Pollack presents how method compilation can enhance performance compared to method_missing, providing examples to illustrate these concepts.
- Microkernel Architecture: A discussion of how Rails 3 utilizes microkernel architecture for better modularity, particularly in the AbstractController design, is presented. This structure improves the organization and readability of Rails code.
- Alias Method Chain vs. Super: Pollack explains using aliasmethodchain and contrasts it with the simplicity of using super for method calls, demonstrating cleaner code practices.
- ActiveSupport Concern: The functionality of ActiveSupport Concern is discussed, showing how it aids in managing modules and improving code organization through class methods and instance methods.
- Catch/Throw Mechanism: Pollack explains the use of catch and throw for control flow, particularly in dependency management within Bundler, which simplifies navigating complex code.

The presentation is filled with numerous code examples and live coding demonstrations that aim to solidify understanding among the audience. Pollack emphasizes the advantages of the refactorings made by Yehuda by discussing their real impacts on Rails.

Conclusions and Takeaways:

Developers are encouraged to dive into the source code of Rails, which, due to its modular design, is now more readable and customizable.
The microkernel architecture allows for flexible creation of tailored solutions, emphasizing creativity and innovation in Ruby on Rails applications.
Pollack invites interaction with the audience, providing opportunities for further questions and discussions, ensuring everyone leaves with an understanding of the techniques covered.

Overall, the talk provides a comprehensive look at complex Ruby design patterns and highlights the significance of Yehuda Katz's contributions to Rails 3.

00:00:10.400 Anyways, I want to get through this talk because I've got a lot of code to show you guys—some really good code, some really sophisticated code, and I want to bring everyone along on that journey.

00:00:16.279 The idea behind this talk is to discuss Yehuda Katz, who has done a lot of refactoring in Rails 3 over the past year and a half.

00:00:22.680 I took a look inside Rails 3 to identify some of the really interesting design patterns that are used and to explain them in a way that everyone could understand, not just Yehuda.

00:00:28.080 When I first started researching, I found that some of the more interesting design patterns were not done just by Yehuda but also by others like Carl Lurch, Josh Peek, and Carl Huda.

00:00:33.480 If you're not familiar, Carl Huda is sort of the alter ego when Yehuda and Carl pair at Engine Yard; they pair under the GitHub name Carl Huda, also known as Emo Cow.

00:00:40.480 Our topics today will look a little something like this: method compilation, microkernel architecture, alias_method_chain vs. super, ActiveSupport concern, catch/throw in Bundler, and increased Rack compatibility.

00:00:46.520 There are going to be a ton of code examples here, and I realize this is before lunch, but if you really focus on the code I explain, you'll find some interesting patterns.

00:00:52.359 Before we get our feet wet, I ask the experts in the room to bear with me for just a minute; I know there are some beginner Ruby developers here, and I don't want to leave them out.

00:01:00.760 So before we dive into advanced topics, let’s revisit the basics to ensure everyone is on the same page.

00:01:06.680 For instance, an attribute accessor is equivalent to saying 'def city' and 'def city='.

00:01:10.480 When we call `initialize`, that's when we use `SimplePrint.new`, and it calls the initialize method.

00:01:16.040 We can set variables within the `initialize` block. When we have `method_missing`, it means that if there's a method call like 's.ruby_conf' and that method doesn’t exist, it will invoke the `method_missing` method.

00:01:21.160 So when we go to the command line and do `SimplePrint.new('Taiwan')`, it sets the city variable, and if we call 's.ruby_conf', we get back 'RubyConf Taiwan'.

00:01:26.280 Now, looking at our code example, we've got a hash, and we're going through each of the keys; we're doing something with eval to create instance variables like name and location.

00:01:34.960 If we do `puts name location`, we're going to get 'BarCamp Orlando'.

00:01:40.479 If we look at instance eval, if we create an instance of a class that prints hello using `puts` and we call that instance, we will receive 'Hello'.

00:01:46.000 Another way to achieve this is through `Test.new.instance_eval` and calling `print`, which yields the same result—it's essentially running the print method in the context of the class.

00:01:51.719 If we create another instance afterwards, though, it won't work because we only added the method to that particular instance.

00:01:56.560 Let's discuss the concept of Classy Val by considering a class called Test. We can extend it to add methods and modify its behavior.

00:02:02.079 If we print the modified class, we’ll see that it outputs 'Ruby 5'.

00:02:10.560 We can achieve this by simply doing `Test.class_eval` as well, which gives us the same output.

00:02:16.960 Now that we have that established, let’s jump into the actual content.

00:02:22.880 We will first look at method compilation. Let's examine a simple example of where we might use this effectively with some straightforward code and then see where this is implemented in Rails 3.

00:02:31.960 For instance, if we use `SimplePrint.new`, we can define methods like 'push', 'pop', and 'top'. Let's say we want a specific output from this code. What code would need to be written inside `SimplePrint` to achieve that?

00:02:39.680 One solution might involve accepting actions as an attribute accessor, creating a print method, and using `method_missing`.

00:02:45.120 When these methods are called, it checks to see if the method matches one initially sent in. If it does, it prints it out.

00:02:50.560 If we run this code 30,000 times, we would find it averages about 5 seconds on my processor.

00:02:56.679 Now, we could write this with method compilation. Here’s how that would look: we define a class called `BetterPrint`, initialize it, and iterate through the items in the provided array.

00:03:04.039 In this case, we would use `instance_eval` to define the methods for each item sent in. This method generates them on-the-fly.

00:03:11.360 When we call these methods, we're invoking the ones generated dynamically, leading to significantly faster performance.

00:03:17.639 Using `method_missing`, it took around 5 seconds. Using `instance_eval`, however, improved execution time to about 3.5 seconds—about 30% faster.

00:03:25.280 Now, you might be wondering what happens under the hood of this performance enhancement. I investigated using Ruby Prof to profile both approaches.

00:03:32.360 In the profiling data, you can see that the `method_missing` version is called repeatedly, checking each time if the string matches before invoking the method.

00:03:40.320 With method compilation, however, methods are merely called, reducing overhead, which ultimately leads to better performance.

00:03:47.440 The first commit that Yehuda made to Rails was implementing method compilation for the mime types, enhancing their performance significantly.

00:03:55.640 Another implementation of method compilation in Rails 3 can be seen with callbacks such as `before_filter`, `after_filter`, and `round_filter`.

00:04:02.680 Rather than checking every filter for every action, Rails compiles a single method that specifies which methods should be called for each action.

00:04:08.880 This method compilation results in a significant speed improvement of about 10 times.

00:04:16.759 For layouts in Rails 3, the old way involved checking types of layout through numerous conditionals each time an action was called.

00:04:25.000 Using method compilation, we can optimize this process, so when the action is called, only the previously defined layout methods are invoked.

00:04:35.560 In the Rails source code, there's a process where if a layout is a string, a method is dynamically created to handle this without repeated checks.

00:04:43.000 This results in the action only needing to call the already defined methods, which improves performance.

00:04:51.000 Now, let's discuss microkernel architecture. A great example of this is seen in the AbstractController in Rails 3, with considerable work done by Carl Lurch.

00:04:58.560 The action controller stack previously included a lot of functionality in one package, which has been effectively separated into more manageable components.

00:05:06.720 For instance, routing and dispatch functionality was moved into Action Dispatch, and a certain hierarchy of modules was established for better organization.

00:05:13.560 In the Rails source, the AbstractController directory illustrates this structure, showcasing one-to-one mapping for common components.

00:05:20.080 By organizing this way, it simplifies learning about callbacks or other functionalities contained in specific files. This provides a clear, concise structure for developers.

00:05:26.560 Now, let’s dive into the code behind the AbstractController base class.

00:05:32.680 The guts of this abstract class is all encapsulated within a single method called 'process'. This method essentially handles requests by calling the relevant action and rendering its output.

00:05:39.320 In addition to the process, it contains a few other necessary methods making up the core functionalities for dispatching.

00:05:45.560 With the microkernel architecture, you layer additional modules on top of the base to enhance its capabilities while keeping things minimal.

00:05:51.880 This layering principle allows for much lighter controllers as we can pick and choose the necessary components.

00:05:59.680 In the context of ActionMailer, it also inherits from AbstractController, reusing much of the foundational code and promoting DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself) principles.

00:06:07.560 Now shifting back to the action controller structure, we see that the 'Metal' layer is where Rack compatibility starts to enter the scene.

00:06:14.680 The core functionality within Metal revolves around the call method, which embodies the entry point for Rack requests.

00:06:22.800 When a request comes in, it calls an action that traverses through the middleware stack before reaching the dispatching method.

00:06:30.560 Importantly, Metal also features methods that facilitate converting requests into Rack-compliant responses.

00:06:38.280 This structure, layered with modules, allows for a more organized and manageable application architecture and contributes to a smoother Rails experience.

00:06:45.760 Let’s take a broader look at the whole stack architecture, starting with AbstractController base all the way up to ActionController base.

00:06:52.760 At the very bottom, we have AbstractController base along with its modules, followed by ActionController Metal, which can be layered as needed.

00:07:01.680 Sitting at the top is ActionController base, including both abstract and metal modules, providing a comprehensive Rails experience.

00:07:07.560 Overall, this microkernel architecture enhances the readability of Rails and encourages developers to engage with the source code.

00:07:15.560 The modular structure allows developers to focus on specific components without feeling overwhelmed.

00:07:22.760 Next, let's make sure we all understand modules and how they function in Ruby, especially in regard to including and extending modules.

00:07:29.640 When including a module, it adds the instance methods, while using 'extend' adds the methods as class methods.

00:07:36.520 To include both instance and class methods simultaneously, you need to employ a modified structure that includes self-included blocks.

00:07:43.520 This is a slightly trickier method that allows for both methods to be available in the respective contexts.

00:07:50.800 With that foundational knowledge out of the way, we can dive deeper into alias method chain versus super.

00:07:57.360 Let's do a quick code challenge. We have a class User that inherits from GenericUser, and we want to output 'Mr. Greg Pollock' when the name method is called.

00:08:04.360 To achieve this without modifying the initial classes, we will leverage metaprogramming to fulfill our goal.

00:08:11.760 One approach would involve creating a module called Mister that utilizes self-included to define our own name method.

00:08:19.560 We could use alias name without Mister and define a new name with Mister, which calls the original method while adding the prefix.

00:08:25.480 However, a more concise way to achieve the same result is to implement alias_method_chain.

00:08:32.720 Using alias_method_chain simplifies the two alias lines into one line, making the code clearer.

00:08:39.960 Nevertheless, there’s an even simpler approach to this, using super. By calling super, we can easily achieve the expected output.

00:08:47.080 This serves as a reminder that when coding properly, you don’t always need to rely on alias_method_chain—super is a cleaner option.

00:08:54.960 In AbstractController, we can see examples of both helpers and their functionalities that utilize super for cleaner code.

00:09:02.880 The abstract controller helpers go through and return a list of all helper modules, while the metal version adds functionality on top by also providing a `helper_all` method.

00:09:10.960 This `helper_all` method allows the controller to access all available helpers, effectively merging functionalities.

00:09:18.360 With these pieces neatly stacked, we can see the benefits of layering modules and the ease of reading the code!

00:09:25.760 Let’s move on to another important topic, which is ActiveSupport Concern, a concept predominantly developed by Josh Peek.

00:09:32.560 For instance, let’s say we have a module called BarCamp2010 with some methods. What goes in that module to make everything work?

00:09:41.560 We can solve it using self-included class eval to set a class method, allowing us to use our module effectively.

00:09:50.680 By incorporating ActiveSupport Concern, we can simplify the process even further.

00:09:58.920 Essentially, calling `included` would internally handle class methods and wrapping what we run with class eval.

00:10:07.240 Active Support performs four main tasks to ease the integration of modules: extending class methods, including instance methods, and running code encapsulated within the included block.

00:10:15.560 Additionally, it ensures that if you have nested modules, the `included` methods run correctly in the base class.

00:10:25.960 This improvement streamlines adding functionality to classes without requiring extra manual efforts.

00:10:34.760 Next, let's look at the concept of catch/throw, which is quite handy for control flow in Ruby.

00:10:43.440 Catch allows you to declare a block where you can subsequently throw, effectively bypassing the remaining code within the block.

00:10:50.960 Interestingly, you can also return values with throws, which introduces a unique aspect of control flow.

00:10:58.560 In projects like Bundler, catch/throw serves as a backend mechanism for dealing with dependencies, allowing easy navigation through complex code.

00:11:06.840 For instance, in resolving a gem requirement, throws enable meaningful jumps in the code flow based on specific conditions.

00:11:12.560 This efficiency makes it easier to manage conflicting dependencies within application structures.

00:11:19.640 In essence, while managing dependencies within depths of Bundler, the use of catch and throw is a powerful technique to simplify that complexity.

00:11:26.480 Now, moving toward the end of the talk, I’d like to leave you with a crucial takeaway: don’t hesitate to dive into the source code.

00:11:33.680 Rails has become much more readable, enabling developers to customize their applications easily.

00:11:41.360 With microkernel architecture and modular design, you have the flexibility to create tailored solutions that cater specifically to your needs.

00:11:48.560 Whether it's crafting a controller for JSON responses for mobile applications or building unique Rails variants, the sky’s the limit.

00:11:57.360 As a final note, feel free to grab the slides from the URL I will provide and don’t forget to rate the talk for feedback.

00:12:05.200 I appreciate everyone coming and participating today, and I also have some stickers available—just come up and grab them.

00:12:12.360 As I conclude, if you are involved in open-source projects or have releases to promote, feel free to talk to me about them.

00:12:20.360 Now, before we wrap up completely, I welcome any questions you might have, and if you're eager to head out for lunch, that's perfectly fine.

00:12:29.160 If you have queries, don't hesitate to approach me afterward or during breaks.

00:12:36.960 Thank you all for being here. Enjoy the rest of the event!

LoneStarRuby Conf 2010